Here are the beer cellar reviews, listed according to their scores. Those graded with identical scores are listed together, without any significance to their internal order.
| Top Scoring | Alphabetical (by beer) | Alphabetical (by brewery) |
| Beer | Brewery | ABV (%) | Comments | Score:/10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Old Growler | Nethergate Brewery | 5.50 | A true winter beer. Deep ruby colours, with smooth roast malts and fruit tangs. Touch of licorice. Better than Pied Boeuf. | 8.5 |
| Newtons Medium Perry | Newtons | 7.00 | Strong pear taste, especially at end. Easy drinking, very good. | 8.5 |
| Lord Lee's | North Yorkshire | 4.70 | Bright and fizzy beer, that's red-brown in colour and twin pairings of malt and sugar. Malt bitter after-taste. | 7.5 |